BEGIN:VCALENDAR VERSION:2.0 PRODID:-//Date iCal//NONSGML kigkonsult.se iCalcreator 2.20.2// METHOD:PUBLISH X-WR-CALNAME;VALUE=TEXT:Eventi DIAG BEGIN:VTIMEZONE TZID:Europe/Paris BEGIN:STANDARD DTSTART:20171029T030000 TZOFFSETFROM:+0200 TZOFFSETTO:+0100 TZNAME:CET END:STANDARD BEGIN:DAYLIGHT DTSTART:20180325T020000 TZOFFSETFROM:+0100 TZOFFSETTO:+0200 TZNAME:CEST END:DAYLIGHT END:VTIMEZONE BEGIN:VEVENT UID:calendar.12993.field_data.0@glad.uniroma1.it DTSTAMP:20260405T091309Z CREATED:20180104T111632Z DESCRIPTION:Should evaluation be democratic or meritocratic?We discuss the problem of the “democratization of evaluation” as the need to provide an a nswer to the injustice generated by the skewness of performance indicators . We introduce another meaning of Altmetrics as an answer to the need of d emocratization of performance indicators. We propose a performance evaluat ion model which might be used as a 'democratic evaluation tool' for value creation in a learning and participatory environment. It may be seen as a revisited version of the Ricardo’s approach of comparative advantages but in the context of a broader framework including theory\, methodology and d ata dimensions. DTSTART;TZID=Europe/Paris:20180111T100000 DTEND;TZID=Europe/Paris:20180111T120000 LAST-MODIFIED:20200521T211813Z LOCATION:Room A3 - DIAG - Via Ariosto 25 SUMMARY:MORE@DIAG: The Problem of Democratization of Evaluation and Altmetr ics - Cinzia Daraio - Cinzia Daraio\n\n\n \n \n\n \n\n\nCinzia\n\n\nD araio \n\n \n\n \n\n\n\n\n\nProfessore Ordinario\n\n\npagina personal e\n\nstanza: \n\nA104\n\ntelefono: \n\n+39 0677274068 \n\n \n\n \n\nB iografia: \n\n\n \n\n\n\n\nPRESENT POSITION\n\n\nCinzia Daraio is Full Pro fessor of Management Engineering at the Department of Computer\, Control a nd Management Engineering Antonio Ruberti\, University of Rome  “La Sapien za” (Italy) where she teaches Efficiency and Productivity Analysis (Master Degree in Management Engineering)\, Quantitative Models for Economic Anal ysis and Management (Master Degree in Data Science)\, Economics and Busine ss Organization (Undergraduate Degree in Electronic Engineering and others ) and Economics (Master Degree in Electrical Engineering). \n\n\nPREVIOUS POSITIONS\n\n\nFrom December 2011 to August 2020 she has been Associate Pr ofessor of Management Engineering at the Department of Computer\, Control and Management Engineering Antonio Ruberti\, University of Rome  “La Sapie nza” (Italy).\n\n\nFrom November 2008 to November 2011 she has been Assist ant Professor at the Department of Management\, Second School of Engineeri ng\, University of Bologna (Italy). From November 2002 to October 2006 she has been research associate at the Institute for Informatics and Telemati cs of the Italian National Research Council (IIT CNR)\, Pisa\, and\, from November 2006 to October 2008\, post-doctoral research fellow and teaching assistant at the Department of Electrical Systems and Automation\, School of Engineering\, University of Pisa (Italy). \n\n\nEDUCATION\n\n\nShe gra duated cum laude in Economics and Business in 1999 at the University of Pi sa and she obtained a Diploma degree in Economics cum laude in 1999 at the  Sant’Anna School of Advanced Studies\, Pisa. She obtained a Master of Art s in Statistics in 2002 at the Université catholique the Louvain (Belgium) \; and she got her Ph.D. in Economics and Management in 2003 at the Sant’A nna School of Advanced Studies\, Pisa (Italy). She is external member of t he Laboratory of Economics and Management (LEM) of the Sant’Anna School of Advanced Studies and has a stable research collaboration with the ISBA In stitute\, Université Catholique de Louvain\, Belgium. \n\n\nRESEARCH INTER ESTS AND PROJECTS\n\nHer research focuses on methodological and empirical studies in productivity and efficiency analysis and performance measuremen t\; development of indicators for the quantitative analysis and evaluation of science\, technology higher education and research policy\, data quali ty and data integration. \n\n \n\nShe has been member of Expert Groups of the European Commission\, namely “Building Composite Indicator(s) on the E uropean Research Area (ERA) implementation”\, Directorate General for Rese arch and Innovation (November 2013-October 2014) and of the “Expert Group to support the development of tailor-made impact assessment methodologies for ERA”\, Directorate General for Research and Innovation (December 2013- October 2014).\n\nShe has been appointed as a member of the Commission of Experts for the Evaluation of the Third Mission Activities (CETM) by the I talian National Agency for the Evaluation of Universities and Research Ins titutions (ANVUR) from October 2015 to May 2017.\n\nShe has a consolidated experience in international and national research projects\, including PR IME (Policies for the Research in the Move towards the European Research A rea) Network of Excellence\, Aquameth (Advanced Quantitative Methods for t he Evaluation of the Performance of Public Sector Research) that she co-co ordinated\; OEU (Observatory on the European University) and ENID (Europea n Network of Indicator Designers)\; Changes in University Incomes tender ( CHINC)\; Innovation Studies (iRiS) Project on “Reorganization of public re search’s technological transfer system: governance\, tools and strategies” and EUMIDA (European Universities Micro Data) Feasibility Study. In parti cular\, in EUMIDA she was national contact point for Italy and coordinated the data collection for Italy through the National Statistical Authority. \n\n \n\nShe coordinated or is coordinating\, or is responsible of the Res earch unit of Sapienza\, in the following projects:\n\n \n\n\n\n\n2019-202 2                               Evaluating Evaluations by Including Normat ive Ethics\, Management Science and Artificial Intelligence in a Visual An alytics Environment (EVAL^2)\, Progetti di Ricerca Medi Sapienza 2019\, N. Protocollo RM11916B8853C925 (11/12/2019-10/12/2022). Coordinator of the p roject.\n\n\n2019-2022                               Research infrastructu res for the assessment of science\, technology and innovation policy 2 (RI SIS 2)\, Grant agreement N° 824091\, European Union H2020 Project. Respons ible of the research unit of Sapienza university of Rome.\n\n\n2017-2019                                Member of the Steering Committee and responsi ble of the research unit of Sapienza university of Rome in the European pr oject  “Implementation and Further Development of the European Tertiary Ed ucation Register ETER III\, Contract No. 934533-2017 A08-CH”\, (22/12/2017 -22/12/2019).\n\n\n2017-2021                               Modelling and M apping the Dynamics of Knowledge. A Co-Creation Indicators Factory Design\ , Progetti H2020 Sapienza 2017 Awards\, N. Protocollo PH11715C8239C105 (21 /11/2017-20/11/2021). Scientific coordinator of the project.\n\n\n2017-202 0                               KOL Project to support the KIMAR Project\, Clarivate Analytics (ex Thomson Reuters)\, USA. Principal Investigator.\n \n\n2017-2020                               PRIN 2015 Prot. 2015RJARX7 Com paring Governance Regime Changes in Higher Education: systemic performance s\, national policy dynamics\, and institutional responses. A multidiscipl inary and mixed methods analysis. Responsible of the research unit of Sapi enza university of Rome (5 February 2017 -5 February 2020).\n\n\nJan 2016- June 2018            Research infrastructures for the assessment of scienc e\, technology and innovation policy (RISIS)\, Grant agreement N° 313082 p roject of the EU FP7 Research Program. Responsible of the research unit of  Sapienza university of Rome.\n\n\n2015-2017                                Member of the Steering Committee and responsible of the research unit of  Sapienza university of Rome in the European project 'Implement and Dissemi nate the European Tertiary Education Register (ETER 2015-2017)'\, Contract No. EAC-2015-0280\, (1-8-2015/31-7-2017).\n\n\n2015-2018                                Scientific coordinator of the Sapienza Project Award Ateneo Sapienza Grandi Progetti Awards 2015 (C26H15XNFS): Establishing a Knowledg e Infrastructure for the Development of Methodologies for the Assessment o f Research and its Impacts (KIMAR\, 30-11-2015/29-11-2018).\n\n\n2013-2016                                Scientific coordinator of the Sapienza Proj ect Award Ateneo Sapienza 2013 (C26A13ZXRY) Efficiency\, Effectiveness and Impact of Universities and Schools (18-12-2013/17-12-2016).\n\n\n2013-201 5                                Member of the Steering Committee and resp onsible of the research unit of Sapienza university of Rome in the Europea n project  'European Tertiary Education Register (ETER)'\, Contract No. EA C-2013-038 (1-8-2013/31-7-2015).\n\n\n2012-2017                                Scientific coordinator of the Elsevier Bibliometric Research Project: Assessing the Scientific Performance of Regions and Countries at Disciplin ary level by means of Robust Nonparametric Methods: new indicators to meas ure regional and national Scientific Competitiveness.\n\n\n2004- 2007                             Co-coordinator (with A. Bonaccorsi) of the project s AQUAMETH (Advanced Quantitative Methods for the evaluation of the perfor mance of Public Sector Research)\, AQUAMETH II and AQUAMETH II Consolidati on\, nell’ambito del FP6-2002-CITIZENS-1 Policies For Research and Innovat ion in the Move Towards the European Research Area (PRIME)\, 1/4/2004-30/9 /2007.\n\n\n2006- 2010  Scientific coordinator of the project “Metodi Avan zati di Benchmarking per la valutazione delle aziende sanitarie toscane”\; commissionato dal Laboratorio di Management e Sanità (MES) della Scuola S uperiore Sant’Anna\, in collaborazione con la Regione Toscana. Fine della prima fase: Aprile 2007. Fase 2: maggio 2007-novembre 2008. Fase 3: maggio 2009-febbraio 2010.\n\n\n2003 Scientific coordinator of the project Giova ni Ricercatori dal titolo: “Analisi di Efficienza/Produttività: studio del le possibilità offerte dalla statistica nonparametrica e dalle tecniche di  bootstrap\; analisi dei vincoli alle applicazioni empiriche\; proposizion e di applicazioni economiche”\, finanziato dalla Scuola Superiore Sant’Ann a\, Pisa.\n\n\n \n\n\n\nMEMBERSHIP\, EDITORIALS AND REVIEWING ACTIVITIES\n \n \n\nShe is member of the International Society of Scientometrics and In formetrics (ISSI)\, of the Consortium of Higher Education Researchers (CHE R)\, of the European Network of Indicators Designers (ENID)\, of the Assoc iation for Information Science and Technology (ASIS&T)\, of the Italian As sociation of Management Engineering (Associazione Italiana di Ingegneria G estionale - AiIG) and Italian Statistical Association (Società Italiana di Statistica -SIS). She is member of the CFEnetwork (specialized teams on: Applied Econometrics\, Computational Econometrics\, Econometric Theory) an d of the Scientific Committee of the biannual European Workshop on Efficie ncy and Productivity Analysis (EWEPA).\n\n \n\nShe is member of the Editor ial Boards of the following journals:\n\n\n22 July 2015- in progress: Asso ciate Editor dell’ International Transactions in Operational Research\, Wi ley\, Impact factor (2018): 2.341.\n1 Settembre 2015- in progress: Associa te Editor of the Journal of Productivity Analysis\; Springer\, Impact fact or (2018): 1.603.\n30 October 2015- in progress: member of the Editorial B oard as Review Editor of Frontiers in Research Metrics and Analytics\, sec tion Research Policy and Strategic Management\, open access journal.\n3 No vember 2015- in progress: member of the Editorial Board of Journal of Data and Information Science (open access journal)\, indexed in Scopus.\n1 Jan uary 2017- in progress: member of the Editorial Board as Distinguished Rev iewer Board member of Scientometrics\, Springer\, Impact factor: 2.770 (20 18). Member of the international “Derek de Solla Price Award” of the Journ al Scientometrics.\n1 January 2020- in progress: member of the Editorial B oard of Quantitative Science Studies\, the official open access journal of the International Society for Scientometrics and Informetrics (ISSI)\, MI T Press.\n23 January 2020- in progress: member of the Editorial Board of   Sustainability\, open access\, journal Impact factor 2.592 (2018).\n15 Jun e-16 November 2020: member of the Topic Editor di “Models in Research Anal ytics”\, Frontiers in Research Metrics and Analytics.\n\n\nShe has been pr oject evaluator for the Rustaveli National Science Foundation. She has bee n external reviewer for the Portuguese Foundation for Science and Technolo gy. \n\nShe is referee for more than 35 international peer-reviewed journa ls.\n\n\n \n\nOTHER AFFILIATIONS\n\n \n\n2003-2014 External member of the Laboratory of Economics and Management (LEM)\, Scuola Superiore Sant’Anna\ , Pisa\, Italy\, and since 2015 research affiliate of the Institute of Eco nomics of Scuola Superiore Sant’Anna.\n\n \n\nLISTED\n\n \n\nShe has been selected and is listed in Who’s Who in The World (since the 2007 Edition) and in Who’s Who in Science and Engineering (since the 10th Edition of the 2007-2008) edited by Marquis Inc.\n\n \n\n\n\n\nAWARDS\n\n\nCinzia Daraio  is listed in the World Top 2% Scientists\, in the field of Social Science s\, sub-fields Information and Library Science and Science Studies\, from 2020 (last update published on October 4\, 2023 available at the following website https://elsevier.digitalcommonsdata.com/datasets/btchxktzyw/6 ). \n\n\nThe World Top 2% Scientists is a ranking developed by Stanford Unive rsity in collaboration with Elsevier and Scopus\; it aims to identify\, am ong the approximately 9 million scientists who contribute scientific artic les\, the top 2% for each discipline in terms of their impact on global sc ientific research over the past year. \n\n\n \n\n\n \n\n\n\n\n\nPUBLICATIO NS AND PAPERS PRESENTED AT CONFERENCES AND IN PROCEEDINGS\n\n \n\n\n\nShe authored a monograph on Advanced Robust and Nonparametric Methods in Effic iency Analysis. Methodology and Applications (with L. Simar) published by Springer (NY) in 2007.\n\n \n\nShe edited two collective books:\n\n- Unive rsities and Strategic Knowledge Creation: Specialization and Performance i n Europe (with A. Bonaccorsi) published by Edward Elgar (Cheltenham) in 20 07\n\n- Evaluative informetrics – the art of metrics-based research assess ment\, Festschrift in honour of Henk F. Moed  (with W. Glänzel) published by Springer Nature in 2020.\n\n \n\nShe edited the following proceedings:  \n\n- Efficiency\, Effectiveness and Impact of Research and Innovation\, P roceedings of the Workshop 20 February 2015 DIAG\, Sapienza University of Rome\, Efesto Edizioni\, Roma\, Maggio 2015\, ISBN 9788899104306.\n\n- Cha llenges of Big Data for Economic Modeling and Management. Tools from Effic iency Analysis\, Sensitivity Analysis\, Sensitivity Auditing and Physics o f Complex Systems\, Proceedings of the Workshop of the 10-11 November 2015 DIAG\, Sapienza University of Rome\, Efesto Edizioni\, Roma\, Febbraio 20 16\, ISBN 9788899104641.\n\n- Proceedings of the 17th International Confer ence on Scientometrics & Informetrics\, 2-5 September 2019\, Sapienza Univ ersity of Rome\, Italy (with Catalano G.\, Gregori M.\, Moed H.F. and Ruoc co G)\, Edizioni Efesto\, ISBN: 978-88-3381-118-5\, August 2019 (2 volumes \, around 2800 pages).\n\n \n\n \n\nShe published several works in interna tional peer-reviewed journals including Cambridge Journal of Economics\, E uropean Journal of Operational Research\, Journal of Productivity Analysis \, Annals of Operations Research\, Research Policy\, Research Evaluation\,   Scientometrics\, Science and Public Policy\, Minerva\, Journal of Inform etrics\, Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology (JASIST)\, Journal of the Operational Research Society\, International Tr ansactions in Operational Research\, Applied Economics\, Journal of Econom ic Surveys\, The Econometrics Journal\, Economic Modelling\, among others. \n\n\n \n\nOverall\, she has more than 300 publications including internat ional peer-reviewed journals\, chapters in books and papers presented at c onferences and in proceedings.\n\n \n\n \n\n\n\n\n \n\n\nPUBLICATIONS AND BIBLIOMETRIC INFORMATION\n\n\n \n\n\nHer list of publications and indicato rs in Google Scholar are available at https://scholar.google.it/citations? user=vx_fhFgAAAAJ&hl=it (h-index= 41 and total number of citations= 8169 o n 6 March 2024).\n\n\nHer bibliometric indicators in Scopus are 122 docume nts\, h-index=31 and total number of citations=3632 on 6 March 2024.\n\n\n Her Scopus author profile is available at: https://www.scopus.com/authid/d etail.uri?authorId=8655852500#\n\n\n\n\n\n\n \n\n\nInteressi di ricerca:  \n\nresearch assessment\nefficiency and productivity analysis\napplied sta tistics/ econometrics\neconomics of education\, economics of science and t echnology\nbibliometrics\nindustrial organization\ndata quality and data i ntegration\n\n\n \n\n\n\n\n\nkeywords: \n\nData qualityEconomics and Mana gement of Education and ResearchEfficiency and Productivity AnalysisEfficie ncy Analysis\n\nqualifica_rr: \n\nProfessors URL;TYPE=URI:http://glad.uniroma1.it/node/12993 END:VEVENT END:VCALENDAR